Student numbers, universities and grades

I think everyone has realised that the government can’t resist fiddling around with the university system.  The removal of subsidies and resulting high fees are the best known, but that’s not all they’re doing.

Their rules on admissions  http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-17871852  are effectively dividing students into “good” (grades ABB or better) and “other”. Universities will be able to take as many “good” students as they like, whatever their fees. However, numbers of  places for “other” students will be cut unless the university charges fees below £7500.

Naturally, they say this is wonderful and all in everyone’s best interests, as “more students will be able to go to their first choice university”.  Er…. not quite.

Firstly – is expansion always a good thing? Do you want to always be swamped in large lecture halls and tutorials, rather than part of a smaller group where the lecturers actually know who you are?  Don’t think expansion is always good for schools – the one I teach in certainly benefits from being small – so I’d imagine it’s the same for universities.

The Russell Group unis, and others that charge fees above 7.5K, will have a disincentive to make offers to students who won’t meet these criteria, whatever the reason – which is likely to hamper their ability to bring in students from non-traditional backgrounds. It may even lead to them shutting some departments who don’t recruit majority ABB students.

Students who miss out on ABB will be really made to feel not wanted by this policy. OK, the government aren’t officially saying “unless you get ABB or above, you’re a bit rubbish”, but it’s going to feel like that.  And universities are likely to make fewer allowances for exceptional circumstances affecting a good candidate’s performance on the day.  It’s probably better for someone who just misses out on an AAB offer and gets ABB (they’ll probably still get taken), but someone who misses out on an ABB offer will be really sunk.

And there is likely to end up being a huge divide between the “ABB universities” and the “7.5K or less universities” – students with officially “good” grades are likely to be reluctant to attend the latter, even if they have the best course, since they will be perceived as less prestigious.  Sure, no-one would say all universities are regarded as the same now – but that’s different to a clear division into two groups. Perhaps they will end up being “universities” and “polytechnics”, as part of Mr Gove’s desire to return to the world of his youth?

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Educational Developments, Exams, Opinions, University Admissions and Careers and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Student numbers, universities and grades

  1. Jesse says:

    Really interesting post – I can’t believe their changing it again!

    I can understand the government’s thinking but it does seem to create as you say a two tier system of universities which can’t be good, can it?

    I was lucky with my course as it wasn’t the most popular course in the world – most lectures has less than 50 of us and tutorials were never, ever more than 6 (I think by the final year there were only about 30 people left on the programme) and they were better the smaller they got.

    Back to your first point I fall into the *other* group at A Level – ACDE and yet somehow managed to pull out a first lol.

    • teacherposts says:

      Yes, it is unbelievable that they can’t leave it alone, isn’t it – and I don’t think enough people know about this one.
      I wish more people would choose less popular courses like you did Jesse – I’m sure it must be a much better experience. I had rather large impersonal lectures, but tutorials were small scale, which is the bit that counted I guess.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s